|
| |

|
2000
NFL Draft - Top Offensive Prospects
By Richard C. Harris
April 14, 2000
Quarterbacks
Unlike last year, when five quarterbacks where taken in the first round, this
years class will likely produce just one first-round selection, Marshalls Chad
Pennington. Pennington (6-3, 229) has all the tools to be a good one -- size, adequate arm
strength, quick release, accuracy, field awareness, athletic ability, and intelligence.
His senior season was his best, when he completed 275 of 405 passes for 3,797 yards and 37
touchdowns, with only 11 interceptions. He placed fifth in the 1999 Heisman voting, earned
Academic All-American honors, and won the coveted Vern Smith award as the conference MVP
while leading his team to a 13-0 season. The knock on Pennington is his ability to throw
the deep ball, but he appears to be ideally suited to play in a West Coast offense.
Besides Pennington, Chris Redman and Giovanni Carmazzi are two QBs that are expected to be
gone by the fourth round. Redman (6-2, 222) is not overly athletic, more of a pure pocket
passer, but his toughness, arm strength, and accuracy will warrant him being taken high in
the draft. Carmazzi (6-3, 224), coming out of Division I-AA Hofstra, has his doubters;
however, his performance at the National Scouting Combine earned him a lot of attention. A
Rhodes Scholar and Academic All-American, Carmazzi has traits very similar to those of
Pennington; in fact, he outperformed the Marshall QB in the 40-yard dash, the vertical and
long jump, and the cone drill (measures change of direction skills). The jury is still out
on the rest of the field. The athletic Tee Martin and the strong-armed Doug Johnson are
two QBs that will likely be taken in the fourth or fifth rounds. A few sleepers in the
group include Joe Hamilton, Jarious Jackson, Travis Brown, and Todd Husak. Hamilton and
Jackson are playmakers, but scouts question Hamiltons size (5-10, 192) and
Jacksons polish. Brown has good size and arm strength but lacks mobility, while
Husaks best attribute is his intelligence. Of this years draft class, Husak
had the highest score on the Wonderlic Test -- the NFLs equivalent to the IQ Test.
|
|
Quarterbacks |
School |
1 |
|
Chad Pennington |
Marshall |
2 |
|
Chris Redman |
Louisville |
3 |
|
Giovanni Carmazzi |
Hofstra |
4 |
|
Tee Martin |
Tennessee |
5 |
|
Doug Johnson |
Florida |
6 |
|
Marc Bulger |
W. Virginia |
7 |
|
Todd Husak |
Stanford |
8 |
|
Tom Brady |
Michigan |
9 |
|
Tim Rattay |
La. Tech |
10 |
|
Travis Brown |
N. Arizona |
11 |
|
Joe Hamilton |
Ga. Tech |
12 |
|
Jarious Jackson |
Notre Dame |
13 |
|
Bill Burke |
Michigan St. |
14 |
|
Tim Lester |
W. Michigan |
15 |
|
Kevin Feterik |
BYU |
Running Backs
As many as four running backs could be taken in the first round this year, and the
field is fairly deep. The leaders of the group are Thomas Jones, Jamal Lewis, Ron
Dayne,
and Shaun Alexander, though none of these young men are guaranteed to be a franchise back.
Jones (5-10, 216) appears to be the back who will be taken first. He has a nice
combination of size and speed (4.48), a solid work ethic, and intelligence. He had a
tremendous senior year, rushing for 1,798 yards and 16 TDs on 334 carries and catching 22
passes for 239 yards and one score, and earning All-America honors. Dayne enters the NFL
with impressive credentials. In his senior season, he finished second in the nation in
rushing with 1,834 yards, won the Heisman Trophy, the Maxwell Award and the Walter Camp
Award as the best football player in America, and the Doak Walker Award as the best
running back in the country. He also was named the MVP of the Rose Bowl for the second
straight year and set an NCAA career rushing mark, breaking the record that Texas' Ricky
Williams set a year earlier. Dayne (5-11, 259) is a bruising runner with 4.5 speed, but
his detractors will note his lack of pass receiving skills and his penchant for injuries.
Alexander (6-0, 218) is a solid all-around back who can score touchdowns (40 in the last
two seasons). He is a very good cut back runner with adequate speed (4.5) and strength. At
5-11, 240 and 4.3 speed, Lewis may have the most upside of the group, but there is some
doubt as to whether he can stay healthy -- he had reconstructive knee surgery in 98
and shoulder problems in 99. He has good instincts, toughness, determination,
balance, and very good hands. If he can avoid major health problems, Lewis could prove to
be the best back of this draft. Other notable backs are Travis Prentice, Curtis
Keaton,
Trung Candiadte, and Michael Wiley. Keaton (5-10, 214) wowed scouts at the Combine with
his 4.4 speed, 41½ " vertical jump, 1011" long jump, and 23 reps with 225
pounds on the bench press. Prentice (5-11, 225, 4.5 speed) rushed for 1,500 yards in each
of his last three seasons at Miami of Ohio, and Canidate and Wiley are burners with 4.3
speed.
|
|
Running
Backs |
School |
1 |
|
Thomas Jones |
Virginia |
2 |
|
Jamal Lewis |
Tennessee |
3 |
|
Ron Dayne |
Wisconsin |
4 |
|
Shaun Alexander |
Alabama |
5 |
|
J.R. Redmond |
Arizona St. |
6 |
|
Travis Prentice |
Miami Ohio |
7 |
|
Curtis Keaton |
James Madison |
8 |
|
Trung Canidate |
Arizona |
9 |
|
Michael Wiley |
Ohio St. |
10 |
|
Shyrone Stith |
Virginia Tech |
11 |
|
Doug Chapman |
Marshall |
12 |
|
Reuben Droughns |
Oregon |
13 |
|
Chrys Chukwuma |
Arkansas |
14 |
|
Rondell Mealey |
LSU |
15 |
|
Ronney Jenkins |
N. Arizona |
16 |
|
Dante Hall |
Texas A&M |
17 |
|
Frank Moreau |
Louisville |
18 |
|
Marlion Jackson |
Saginaw Valley |
19 |
|
Frank Murphy |
Kansas St. |
20 |
|
Morgan Kane |
Wake Forest |
21 |
|
Kevin McDougal |
Colorado St. |
Fullbacks
Not too much to get excited about here. The better blockers, such as Aaron Shea and
Deon Dyer, have limited rushing and receiving skills, while the more talented backs, such
as Sammy Morris and Paul Smith are undersized for the position.
|
|
Fullbacks |
School |
1 |
|
Sammy Morris |
Texas Tech |
2 |
|
Aaron Shea |
Michigan |
3 |
|
Deon Dyer |
N. Carolina |
4 |
|
Mike Green |
Houston |
5 |
|
Paul Smith |
UTEP |
6 |
|
Terrell Smith |
Arizona St. |
7 |
|
Dan Kendra |
Florida St. |
8 |
|
Aaron Harris |
Penn St. |
Wide Receivers
This group has a wealth of talent; for example, All-American and Biletnikoff-Award
winner Troy Walters is 25th on my list. The most coveted player in the group is
the game-breaking Peter Warrick. Though he does not have great size (5-11, 194) or speed
(4.5), he is an exceptional athlete that can deliver big plays with his ability to run
with the ball after the catch. Plaxico Burress, who at 6-5, 231 has drawn comparisons to
Randy Moss, closely follows Warrick. With 4.5 speed Burress is not as fast as Moss, but
his height, strength, and leaping ability should cause many problems for opposing
cornerbacks. Though Burress may have the most upside of any receiver in the draft, he may
be the third or fourth WR taken because of perceived attitude problems. After
Burress,
there are a number of receivers that have first-round potential. These players include Dez
White, Travis Taylor, Jerry Porter, Dennis Northcutt, Sylvester Morris, R. Jay
Soward, and
Todd Pinkston. White, Taylor, Morris, and Pinkston all stand six feet or taller and have
4.4 speed. Northcutt (5-10, 175) is not as tall as those four, but he has big-play ability
similar to Warrick, and 4.4 speed to match. Soward (5-9, 177), Laveranues Coles, and Chris
Cole are the three fastest receivers in the draft, running the forty in the 4.3 range. The
hidden gem may be Porter. A quarterback in high school and used mostly at free safety at
West Virginia, he is somewhat of an unknown commodity. As a receiver in college, he
totaled just 28 receptions. Even so, scouts are drooling over Porters skill set.
Standing 6-2 and weighing 221, he runs the forty in 4.34 and has an unbelievable vertical
leap of 44½ inches. The talent does not stop with Porter. Draft expert Mel Kiper calls
Ron Dugans the 19th best player in the entire draft, and Muneer Moore, Trevor
Gaylor, and Mareno Philyaw are receivers from small schools, who have good height, speed,
and leaping ability.
|
|
Wide
Receivers |
School |
1 |
|
Peter Warrick |
Florida St. |
2 |
|
Plaxico Burress |
Michigan St. |
3 |
|
Dez White |
Ga. Tech |
4 |
|
Travis Taylor |
Florida |
5 |
|
Jerry Porter |
W. Virginia |
6 |
|
Dennis Northcutt |
Arizona |
7 |
|
Sylvester Morris |
Jackson St. |
8 |
|
R. Jay Soward |
USC |
9 |
|
Todd Pinkston |
So. Miss |
10 |
|
Danny Farmer |
UCLA |
11 |
|
Anthony Lucas |
Arkansas |
12 |
|
Ron Dugans |
Florida St. |
13 |
|
Laveranues Coles |
Florida St. |
14 |
|
Darrell Jackson |
Florida |
15 |
|
Chris Cole |
Texas A&M |
16 |
|
Muneer Moore |
Richmond |
17 |
|
Kwame Cavil |
Texas |
18 |
|
Trevor Gaylor |
Miami Ohio |
19 |
|
Mareno Philyaw |
Troy State |
20 |
|
Sherrod Gideon |
So. Miss |
21 |
|
JaJuan Dawson |
Tulane |
22 |
|
Quinnton Spotwood |
Syracuse |
23 |
|
Bashir Yamini |
Iowa |
24 |
|
Chafie Fields |
Penn St. |
25 |
|
Troy Walters |
Stanford |
26 |
|
Marcus Knight |
Michigan |
Tight End
It is almost unanimous that Daniel "Bubba" Franks out of Miami of Florida is
the best tight end in the draft and will be taken in the first round. At 6-6, 265, Franks
is a big target and can be a physical blocker. He also possesses good hands and the
ability to make circus-type catches. His downside is that he does not have exceptional
speed (4.8). Anthony Becht is likely to be the next tight end taken, and he could go as
high as the second round. Becht (6-6, 270) is not extraordinary in any one area, but is a
solid all-around tight end with a good head on his shoulders. Erron Kinney, James Whalen,
and Dave Stachelski are also solid prospects who are likely to be taken in rounds three
through five.
|
|
Tight
Ends |
School |
1 |
|
Bubba Franks |
Miami |
2 |
|
Anthony Becht |
W. Virginia |
3 |
|
Erron Kinney |
Florida |
4 |
|
James Whalen |
Kentucky |
5 |
|
Dave Stachelski |
Boise St. |
6 |
|
Jay Tant |
Northwestern |
7 |
|
Mondriel Fulcher |
Miami |
8 |
|
Jason Gavadza |
Kent |
9 |
|
Austin Wheatley |
Iowa |
10 |
|
Casey Crawford |
Virginia |
11 |
|
John Jones |
Indiana Pa. |
12 |
|
Zeron Flemister |
Iowa |
13 |
|
Ibn Green |
Louisville |
14 |
|
Kyle Allamon |
Texas Tech |
Center
This is another position where one player appears to be a head above the rest, and that
player is John St. Clair out of Virginia. Though St. Clair (6-5, 302) has great size, he
is not considered a prototypical center and lacks some experience, which equates to him
being taken in the second or third round. The other top prospect at the position is Brad
Meester from Northern Iowa. Meester (6-3, 298) is very smart and athletic, but not overly
powerful.
|
|
Centers |
School |
1 |
|
John St. Clair |
Virginia |
2 |
|
Brad Meester |
N. Iowa |
3 |
|
Rob Riti |
Missouri |
4 |
|
John Romero |
California |
5 |
|
Matt O'Neal |
Oklahoma |
6 |
|
Seneca Gray |
Kentucky St. |
7 |
|
Mike Malano |
San Diego St. |
8 |
|
Mike McLaughlin |
Stanford |
9 |
|
Ty Wise |
Miami |
10 |
|
Spencer Riley |
Tennessee |
Guard
There are some very solid players in this group, but none may be taken in the first
round. It is likely that the top two or three will go in the second round, and seven of
the top ten will be gone by the end of the fourth. The top two prospects are Travis
Claridge and Cosey Coleman. Claridge (6-5, 303) is very durable and prides himself on
being ready to play every week. He is also versatile, able to line up at either guard slot
or at right tackle. At USC for four years, he started every game of his career. He moved
from guard to right tackle in '99 and had the best season of his collegiate career.
Coleman (6-4, 322) is considered one of the strongest players in the draft, but is still
not a polished lineman. He did not impress the scouts at the Combine, looking somewhat out
of shape, but he will merit a lot of consideration because of his size, athleticism, and
upside potential.
|
|
Guards |
School |
1 |
|
Travis Claridge |
USC |
2 |
|
Cosey Coleman |
Tennessee |
3 |
|
Chad Clifton |
Tennessee |
4 |
|
Leander Jordan |
Indiana Pa |
5 |
|
Bobby Williams |
Arkansas |
6 |
|
Kaulana Noa |
Hawaii |
7 |
|
Tutan Reyes |
Mississippi |
8 |
|
Cooper Carlisle |
Florida |
9 |
|
Brad Bedell |
Colorado |
10 |
|
Ryan Johanningmeier |
Colorado |
11 |
|
Mark Tauscher |
Wisconsin |
12 |
|
Richard Mercier |
Miami |
13 |
|
Jeno James |
Auburn |
14 |
|
Michael Moore |
Troy State |
15 |
|
Manuia Savea |
Arizona |
16 |
|
Noel LaMontagne |
Virginia |
17 |
|
Andrew Kline |
San Diego St. |
Tackle
This position is well stocked at the top. The top nine players on this list are
expected to be gone by the end of the third round, with as many as five going in the
first. The top three, Chris Samuels, Stocker McDougle, and Chris McIntosh are considered
locks to be among the first 31 picks. Samuels (6-5, 325) is generally considered one of
the top five players in the draft, but some NFL teams are concerned over his medical
history. He had shoulder surgery after the '98 season and had a sore right knee for most
of the '99 season. That knee was scoped in January, forcing him to miss the Senior Bowl
and the Combine workout. In his senior season at Alabama, he earned All-American honors,
and won the Outland Trophy as the top lineman in the nation and the Jacobs Award as the
best blocker in the SEC. McDougle is a house of a man, weighing in at 361 pounds. He plays
with a nasty streak and displays great natural strength. He does lack quickness and is
best suited to play right tackle. Another concern is his weight, which he struggles to
keep under control. McIntosh (6-6, 315) is another huge specimen with superior strength.
He excels in run blocking, but does struggle at times with the outside pass rush. Playing
at left tackle for Wisconsin, he earned Academic All-Big Ten all four years and was named
an All-American in 99.
|
|
Tackles |
School |
1 |
|
Chris Samuels |
Alabama |
2 |
|
Stockar McDougle |
Oklahoma |
3 |
|
Chris McIntosh |
Wisconsin |
4 |
|
Marvel Smith |
Arizona St. |
5 |
|
Todd Wade |
Mississippi |
6 |
|
Adrian Klemm |
Hawaii |
7 |
|
Michael Thompson |
Tennessee St. |
8 |
|
Darnell Alford |
Boston Col. |
9 |
|
Joe Chustz |
La. Tech |
10 |
|
Damion McIntosh |
Kansas St. |
11 |
|
Mark Baniewicz |
Syracuse |
12 |
|
Greg Randall |
Michigan St. |
13 |
|
Jon Carman |
Ga. Tech |
14 |
|
Shane Cook |
Colorado |
15 |
|
John Blick |
Penn St. |
|
| |
|